Rivnitz Donate

Why does a relationship with Hashem need private time, not just the crowd?

By Rabbi Shalom Landau.

Rabbi Landau teaches that a rally can have fifty thousand people. It's loud, everybody's excited, it's beautiful. “But if you really need something from the president, you don't want another rally. You want 10 minutes alone in the room.”

“Because there are things you can say in a crowd, and there are things you can only say when it's just you and him. No audience, no images, no performance, just the truth.”

Every real relationship, he says, eventually needs that room, “where you stop explaining yourself to everybody else, where you stop pretending, where you can finally say, ‘This is where I messed up. This is what I need. This is who I really am.’”

That is what these days ask of us with Hashem. “The crowd has its place, but a private meeting can change everything.” In the words of the verse, “Lifnei Hashem titharu,” before Hashem you shall be purified: no audience, no performance, just you and Hashem.

Watch Rabbi Landau's teaching

Related concepts: Prayer that starts in the heart · Truth

In A Soul at Peace: A Crowd for the King, and a Private Room with Him

Also answered in this teaching

How can I make room for a private moment with Hashem?

In A Soul at Peace, Rabbi Landau suggests taking a few minutes after a good prayer, before going back into the noise of the day. No phone, no audience, no show; then say to Hashem in your own words, “Here I am. This is what is hard for me. This is what I need.”

Going deeper: Rabbi Landau's teaching, level by level

Surface claim

The crowd has its place, but some things can only be said alone in the room.

Fear, vulnerability, or tension

In front of others we keep explaining ourselves and performing. Rabbi Landau describes the private room as the place where you stop pretending.

Underlying need or longing

To be able to say honestly: this is where I messed up, this is what I need, this is who I really am.

Deepest human truth

Every real relationship eventually needs that room. Before Hashem you shall be purified: no audience, no performance, just you and Hashem.

More answers: The Cycle of Renewal: Elul, Holidays, and Light · All questions · Questions about Rabbi Landau and Rivnitz

Follow us on Facebook