Rivnitz Donate

Draft edition

By Rabbi Shalom Landau.

The Light That Comes as a Free Gift

Opening Three days of Hanukkah. We have already lit the candles. We have already said the blessings. We have already watched the light spread. You might ask: what is so different about the third candle? Adding one more candle each night is a fixed rule. It is simple, and everyone knows it. What is new here? But know this: the adding is not only about quantity. On the third day, a completely new quality is revealed. Let us explain. First Step: Something That Stays, and Compassion Jewish law has a well-known rule about an “established presumption”: something that happens three times becomes an established fact. On the third day, the light becomes established as a fact in the world. It is no longer an experiment. It is no longer a bright new surprise. It is already here: fixed and real. What does it mean that the light is now fixed? The number three points to one of the divine qualities through which Hashem relates to the world: the quality of harmony. This was the special trait of our forefather Jacob. Kindness belongs to Abraham, an abundance that flows out in every direction. Strength and restraint belong to Isaac, holding back and judging strictly. But harmony is the quality of compassion. It sweetens harsh judgments and blends them together. It reveals a light that is neither reward nor punishment, only simple, tender mercy. Compassion is not payment for what you did. Compassion is a gift. Think of a father who feels compassion for his son. The father does not first check whether his son succeeded, whether he tried hard, or whether he “deserves it.” The compassion comes before any calculation. Rabbi Schneur Zalman of Liadi, author of the Tanya, wrote this in one of his holy letters. There is a kind of giving that comes as payment for work. There is also a higher kind: an abundance given as a completely free gift, beyond any measuring of what you earned or what you owe. This is the light of the third candle. It is not a light you earned. It is a light that was given to you. Second Step: Where the Light Reaches There is something deeper here. Where does this light reach? The holy Zohar, the classic book of Jewish mysticism, speaks of an “awakening from above.” This is an awakening that comes from Above and does not wait for us to awaken first from below. Some higher revelations a person “invites” through his inner work. But there is also a revelation that comes on its own. You did not ask for it, and you did not prepare yourself to receive it. And where does this revelation come? Precisely there. In his book Likkutei Torah, Rabbi Schneur Zalman explains a verse from the Song of Songs: “I am asleep, but my heart is awake.” He teaches that sometimes a person’s inner powers are asleep. They are cut off and not working. The soul seems far away. And precisely there, and precisely then, “my heart is awake.” The divine core inside a person stays awake and keeps working, even while the person himself is asleep. Maybe you feel you have fallen asleep spiritually. You tried and did not succeed. You asked and were still left lacking. In one corner of your life you stopped expecting and stopped hoping, because you told yourself, “I don’t deserve it anymore.” Know that precisely there, a different kind of light is waiting for you. It is not a light that found you because you earned it. It is a light that found you because you are His child. Remember: our forefather Jacob was shown the ladder to heaven while he was running away. It came at his lowest moment, when he was alone on the ground. It did not come at a time of greatness or at a time when he had proven his worth. It was a completely free gift, coming down to the lowest place of all.

Putting It into Practice

About the Hanukkah candles our Sages teach: “It is forbidden to use their light.” We may only look at them. This is a very deep lesson. Your inner work on this third night is not to do, to conquer or to prove. Your work is to agree to see. Let go of the calculation “Am I worthy?” Allow the good to surprise you. The effort here is an effort of setting the self aside. It is not about “doing.” It is about “allowing.” There is a goodness from Hashem that does not depend on your success. It comes because it comes, out of simple compassion that is beyond every calculation. If there is a rescue you have stopped asking for, let it come. If there is help you told yourself “I don’t deserve,” let it arrive. Let the light do its work.

Questions and answers

Q: What is new about the third night of Hanukkah if we add one candle every night anyway?

Rabbi Landau answers: Three days of Hanukkah. We have already lit the candles. We have already said the blessings. We have already watched the light spread. You might ask: what is so different about the third candle? Adding one more candle each night is a fixed rule. It is simple, and everyone knows it. What is new here? But know this: the adding is not only about quantity. On the third day, a completely new quality is revealed. Let us explain.

Q: How does the legal rule that three times makes an “established presumption” apply to the third Hanukkah candle?

Rabbi Landau answers: Jewish law has a well-known rule about an “established presumption”: something that happens three times becomes an established fact. On the third day, the light becomes established as a fact in the world. It is no longer an experiment. It is no longer a bright new surprise. It is already here: fixed and real. What does it mean that the light is now fixed? The number three points to one of the divine qualities through which Hashem relates to the world: the quality of harmony. This was the special trait of our forefather Jacob. Kindness belongs to Abraham, an abundance that flows out in every direction.

Q: What is the “awakening from above” in the Zohar, and where does the Hanukkah light reach?

Rabbi Landau answers: There is something deeper here. Where does this light reach? The holy Zohar, the classic book of Jewish mysticism, speaks of an “awakening from above.” This is an awakening that comes from Above and does not wait for us to awaken first from below. Some higher revelations a person “invites” through his inner work. But there is also a revelation that comes on its own. You did not ask for it, and you did not prepare yourself to receive it. And where does this revelation come? Precisely there.

Q: Is the third Hanukkah candle really any different from the first two?

Rabbi Landau answers: You might ask: what is so different about the third candle?

Q: What does the rule that we may not use the Hanukkah light teach about our inner work?

Rabbi Landau answers: About the Hanukkah candles our Sages teach: “It is forbidden to use their light.” We may only look at them. This is a very deep lesson. Your inner work on this third night is not to do, to conquer or to prove. Your work is to agree to see. Let go of the calculation “Am I worthy?” Allow the good to surprise you. The effort here is an effort of setting the self aside. It is not about “doing.” It is about “allowing.” There is a goodness from Hashem that does not depend on your success. It comes because it comes, out of simple compassion that is beyond every calculation. If there is a rescue you have stopped asking for, let it come.

Follow us on Facebook