Rivnitz Donate

Draft edition

By Rabbi Shalom Landau.

Whoever Loves Money Never Has Enough

“Whoever loves money will never have enough money, and whoever loves wealth will never have enough gain. This too is empty.” A Simple Question Here is a simple question. It has never really been answered the way it should be. A Jew works for years. He builds a business. He reaches what he dreamed of. And then, instead of resting, he starts chasing the next number. It is not because he lacks anything. It is not because he is hungry. It is because the “finish line” has moved again. It is as if someone moves the post forward at the very moment you touch it. What is going on here? Is it ambition? A drive to grow? A need for honor? It is worth looking at this more deeply. The Verse and the Parable King Solomon wrote: “Whoever loves money will never have enough money.” He did not say that money is bad. He did not say that a rich man is a sinner. He stated a simple fact: whoever loves money will never have enough of it. Why? Because money, by its very nature, cannot satisfy the one who loves it. The Midrash explains this with a sharp parable. Just as whoever loves money will never have enough, so too “whoever has a hundred wants two hundred.” Every gain only makes the desire bigger. It does not fill it. Let us be precise. The Talmud says plainly: “A person’s evil inclination grows stronger against him every day.” The evil inclination is the inner voice that pulls us toward wrong. From the teachings of the early sages comes a beautiful parable about drinking salt water. A thirsty person who drinks salt water only gets thirstier the more he drinks. It is not that the water never reached him. It is that salt, by its nature, dries a person out from the inside. Money is exactly like this. The problem is not that the number is too small. The problem is that a number, by its nature, cannot put out the thirst. The Inner and the Outer Here is the real new insight. Rabbi Schneur Zalman of Liadi, author of the Tanya, the classic book of Hasidic thought, explains it in a way that cannot be ignored. In chapter one, he writes that the animal soul is “a real thing that stands on its own.” The animal soul is the part of us driven by bodily wants. It is not some in-between state, and it is not nonsense. It is a real inner force with real desires. By its nature, it is never satisfied by the pleasures of the body and the material world. This is not a moral flaw. It is simply its nature. This leads to the main point: “A person who does not have enough on the inside will never feel he has enough on the outside.” If a person feeds only the animal soul, the chase will never end. This is not because he is ambitious. It is because he is building on sand. The “finish line” moves not because you succeeded. It moves because your inner soul, your divine soul, is still empty. In chapter twelve, Rabbi Schneur Zalman explains that the desires of this world are “the darkness and folly of the dark side,” and they are never satisfied. The cause is not their amount. The cause is their nature. In one of his letters, he teaches that true joy, a joy that lasts, comes from matters of heaven. It comes from a person’s inner side, not from success on the outside. The Real Solution This does not mean we should withdraw from the world. Hasidic teaching does not teach running away. It teaches order. The idea is this: first build the “inside.” As we learn in the Ethics of the Fathers: “Who is rich? The one who is happy with his share.” Our Sages did not say “the one who has a big share.” They said the one who is happy with his share. Being rich is a state of the inner self, not a number in a bank account. When the divine soul gets its food, which is Torah, commandments and real prayer, a person feels something inside that money cannot buy: fulfillment. From that fulfillment, earning a living takes on a different proportion. It stops being “oxygen,” something you cannot live without, and becomes a vessel. It has a job, it has a limit, and it has an owner. And the “finish line” stops moving. This is not because you reached the right number. It is because you understood that the number was never the question.

Putting It into Practice

Every day, sit for ten minutes before you open the laptop and before you look at your account. Sit and ask yourself: What do I already have that is not oxygen, but a gift? This is not an exercise in cheap gratitude. It is an exercise in building the “inside.” One day of a feeling like this is worth more than the next “finish line.”

Questions and answers

Q: Which verse in Ecclesiastes says whoever loves money will never have enough money?

Rabbi Landau answers: “Whoever loves money will never have enough money, and whoever loves wealth will never have enough gain. This too is empty.”

Q: Why does someone who reached his financial dream keep chasing the next number?

Rabbi Landau answers: Here is a simple question. It has never really been answered the way it should be. A Jew works for years. He builds a business. He reaches what he dreamed of. And then, instead of resting, he starts chasing the next number. It is not because he lacks anything. It is not because he is hungry. It is because the “finish line” has moved again. It is as if someone moves the post forward at the very moment you touch it. What is going on here? Is it ambition? A drive to grow? A need for honor? It is worth looking at this more deeply.

Q: How does the Tanya's teaching on the animal soul explain why we are never satisfied?

Rabbi Landau answers: Here is the real new insight. Rabbi Schneur Zalman of Liadi, author of the Tanya, the classic book of Hasidic thought, explains it in a way that cannot be ignored. In chapter one, he writes that the animal soul is “a real thing that stands on its own.” The animal soul is the part of us driven by bodily wants. It is not some in-between state, and it is not nonsense. It is a real inner force with real desires. By its nature, it is never satisfied by the pleasures of the body and the material world. This is not a moral flaw. It is simply its nature.

Q: What is the real solution to never having enough, according to "Who is rich? The one who is happy with his share"?

Rabbi Landau answers: This does not mean we should withdraw from the world. Hasidic teaching does not teach running away. It teaches order. The idea is this: first build the “inside.” As we learn in the Ethics of the Fathers: “Who is rich? The one who is happy with his share.” Our Sages did not say “the one who has a big share.” They said the one who is happy with his share. Being rich is a state of the inner self, not a number in a bank account. When the divine soul gets its food, which is Torah, commandments and real prayer, a person feels something inside that money cannot buy: fulfillment. From that fulfillment, earning a living takes on a different proportion.

Q: What daily exercise does Rabbi Landau suggest for building the inside?

Rabbi Landau answers: Every day, sit for ten minutes before you open the laptop and before you look at your account. Sit and ask yourself: What do I already have that is not oxygen, but a gift? This is not an exercise in cheap gratitude. It is an exercise in building the “inside.” One day of a feeling like this is worth more than the next “finish line.”

Follow us on Facebook